I recently finished reading the book American Grace by Robert D. Putnam and David E. Campbell (you can read my Goodreads review of it here). The book gives an overall snapshot of the nation’s religiosity by presenting the results of the authors’ extensive Faith Matters surveys. In the last chapter, they give some very interesting, and seemingly contradictory, data about Mormons and our beliefs.
First, they report the percentage of respondents from different faiths who said that they agreed with the statement, “People not of my faith, including non-Christians, can go to heaven.” The authors interpret this data point as the tolerance that a given faith engenders. The higher the percentage, the more accepting the people in the religion are of others and their beliefs. Mormons, surprisingly enough, had the highest percentage of all at 98 percent; almost all Mormons believe that non-Mormons, and even non-Christians can make it to heaven. I was very happy when I read this. Apparently, most Mormons understand Mormon doctrine. In light of this, though, the next statistic presented could be perplexing to a person unfamiliar with Mormonism.
Next, the authors present the statistics for what percentage of people agreed with the statement, “One religion is true and others are not.” They describe those that agree with this statement as “hard-core, deeply moralistic [and] less tolerant.” Mormons scored highest in this category as well with almost 30 percent of Mormon respondents agreeing. (I am a little disappointed that the percentage is so low. Yes, there are truths taught in other religions but if I had to definitively say that I agree or disagree with this statement, as a Mormon, I would have to agree.)
How is it possible for Mormons to be, at the same time, the most tolerant and least tolerant religion in America? The answer lies in understanding two important points of Mormon doctrine.